
5251 Caleb Hl Rd
45133
HillsboroAsking price
$419,000
$160 / ft²Amy Davis
Request to be contacted by Amy Davis
Family home for sale in Hillsboro, OH
This family home, built in 1975, offers 2628 sq ft of living space across 6 rooms. The property includes 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. The interior features a family room equipped with a custom bar and a pellet stove, providing direct access to an outdoor patio. The kitchen is designed with an island and opens onto a wrap-around deck that overlooks the surrounding pasture and a spring-fed, stocked pond.
Exterior features include 14.6 acres of fenced land. The property is equipped with a 24x60 pole barn featuring 4 stalls and a lean-to, along with an additional shed for animals. Recent updates to the home include new windows installed in 2024, hardy siding, and a roof that is approximately 10 years old.
Located in Hillsboro, this property is situated in a rural setting that provides space and privacy. The area is characterized by its agricultural landscape and natural surroundings, offering a quiet environment while remaining accessible to the local amenities of Highland County.
Amenities
Oven/Range
Electric Water Heater
Oven
Dishwasher
Refrigerator
Dryer
Range
Washer
Asking price
$419,000
$160 / ft²Amy Davis
Request to be contacted by Amy Davis
Property information
House details
Asking price
Asking price per ft²
Listed since
Transfer date
Status
House features
Building year
Surface and layout
Living area
Plot size
Rooms
Similar properties for sale in Hillsboro
Recommended buyer agents that can help you purchase this home
Adam Coleman
Real Estate Agent at COLEMAN REAL ESTATE
Helping buyers win and sellers maximize every deal in the Akron market. Smart strategy, strong negotiation, relentless effort and enthusiasm —built to get results.
Richard Tebbe
Real Estate Agent at red 1 realty
Richard “Rick” Tebbe has been a licensed Ohio real estate professional since 2005, serving buyers, sellers, and investors throughout Greater Dayton and the Miami Valley. With more than two decades of experience across multiple market cycles, Rick provides straightforward, informed guidance tailored to each client’s goals—not a one-size-fits-all approach. Based at Red 1 Realty, Rick personally manages his clients’ transactions, from initial consultation through negotiation and closing. He works with first-time buyers, families, sellers, relocation clients, and real estate investors, including residential and larger investment opportunities. His investment experience provides added perspective on market fundamentals, property potential, and long-term value. A member of the National Association of REALTORS® and Dayton REALTORS®, Rick is committed to professionalism, ethical service, communication, and Equal Housing Opportunity. Clients can reach Rick directly at 937-474-5334.

Sheldon Oliver-Peukert
Real Estate Agent at eXp Realty
Hi neighbors! I’m Sheldon, a local realtor who loves helping people find the right fit—whether that’s a first home, a forever home, or selling with confidence. What sets me apart? I don’t just focus on the transaction—I connect you with trusted lenders, contractors, and community resources so the process feels smooth and stress-free. No pressure, just real conversations about your goals. If you’re curious about the market or what your options look like, I’d love to chat.
Amy J Davis
Real Estate Agent at Donald E Fender Inc
Sue C. Boone
Real Estate Agent at Sue Boone Realty Inc
Jason Gardner
Real Estate Agent at Point Realty Llc
Anyone explained by Max
The easy way to buy & sell properties, explained. No jargon, just Max.
Video: anyone for buyers
Find out how much you can afford
Our simple mortgage calculator will give you a clear understanding of how much you can afford, helping you make informed decisions before placing an offer on a property.
Estimate my mortgage



























