
39 Starr Ave
12701
MonticelloAsking price
$899,999
$300 / ft²Eidel Moses
Request to be contacted by Eidel Moses
Family home for sale at 39 Starr Ave, Monticello, NY 12701
This family home, built in 1957, offers 2,952 square feet of living space across 10 rooms. The property includes 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms. The interior features a grand foyer with marble floors, a living room with a fireplace and floor-to-ceiling windows, and an office with wood-paneled walls. Stained glass details are present throughout the home. The finished basement provides two additional rooms, and the property includes a garage.
Outdoor features include a patio, an in-ground pool, and a pool house set on 1.25 acres of land.
Monticello is located in Sullivan County, known for its access to the Catskill Mountains and regional outdoor recreation. The area provides a mix of residential settings with proximity to local amenities and major road connections for travel throughout the region.
Amenities
Oven
Dishwasher
Refrigerator
Hot Water: Electric Stand Alone
Convection Oven
Corner
PoolDescription-In-ground
Patio-Patio
Asking price
$899,999
$300 / ft²Eidel Moses
Request to be contacted by Eidel Moses
Property information
House details
Asking price
Asking price per ft²
Listed since
Transfer date
Status
House features
Building year
Surface and layout
Living area
Plot size
Floors
Rooms
Similar properties for sale in Monticello
Recommended buyer agents that can help you purchase this home

Michael E. Smith
Real Estate Agent at Lokel Realty Group
MICHAEL E. SMITH — PRINCIPAL BROKER (LICENSED SINCE 2013) Michael E. Smith is a Principal Broker at Lokel Realty with over 12 years of experience navigating the Brooklyn and Manhattan real estate markets. Licensed since 2013, Michael has built a reputation for honest counsel, meticulous attention to detail, and a genuinely client-first approach. Michael understands that no two clients — and no two properties — are the same. He listens carefully, advises honestly, and advocates fiercely on behalf of the people he represents. His expertise spans condos, co-ops, townhomes, and multi-family investments across Williamsburg, the Upper East Side, and Midtown Manhattan. His thorough knowledge of New York City's market allows him to spot opportunity, anticipate challenges, and guide clients to confident decisions. Whether you're buying your first home or expanding your real estate portfolio, Michael brings the professionalism, dedication, and market insight to help you succeed. License #: 10991239704 Affiliations: Member, Real Estate Board of New York (REBNY) Member, New York State Association of REALTORS® Member, National Association of REALTORS® Education: Valencia College Languages: English, Spanish Speciality: Condominiums, cooperatives, townhouses, brownstones, and multi-family investment properties. Area Covered: Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens Years of Experience: 12
Andrew Ziff
Real Estate Agent at NY Living Solutions at Keller Williams NYC
Andrew is the Founder of the NY Living Solutions Team at Keller Williams NYC and a respected leader in New York City real estate. Alongside Michael, he has built a top-performing team known for strong results and personalized service, operating from their Financial District storefront. Formed in 2021, the team offers clients enhanced resources and market expertise across sales, rentals, and development. Backed by Keller Williams’ global network of over 200,000 agents, Andrew provides a competitive advantage through technology, reach, and collaboration. He is a member of REBNY, NAR, and OneKey MLS, and is licensed in New York and New Jersey.
Anderson Calixte
Real Estate Agent at MYNY
Brenda Gaebel
Real Estate Agent at Sullivan Realty Associates
Catherine Eichner
Real Estate Agent at Cronin & Company Real Estate
Kala Jackson
Real Estate Agent at Keller Williams Hudson Valley
Anyone explained by Max
The easy way to buy & sell properties, explained. No jargon, just Max.
Video: anyone for buyers
Find out how much you can afford
Our simple mortgage calculator will give you a clear understanding of how much you can afford, helping you make informed decisions before placing an offer on a property.
Estimate my mortgage

























